Despite being a small archipelago, Key Largo is a melting pot of diverse cultures and food scenes. Find island-inspired food, seafood restaurants, brunch cafes, and barbecue spots that we’re sure you’ll be coming back to.
Given the island’s location, Key Largo is known as a town filled with good seafood restaurants, and the island certainly doesn’t disappoint! From Latin, Cuban, Mexican, Asian, and everything in between, there’s always something in store for everyone here in the Keys.
To give you a headstart on your next visit to the Keys, we collected the 28 best restaurants in Key Largo that you should definitely give a try. Let’s hop in!
Seafood:
Here are the best seafood restaurants in Key Largo for those of you who want a fresh bite from the sea.
Keys Bite
Keys Bite is one of the multi-cultural fusion restaurants that adapted to the local’s diverse palate. It is Hispanic-oriented, but their menu has something in store for every preference. They also have vegetarian and vegan options, which is a good plus.
Try their mahi-mahi, shrimp, and scallops for lunch or dinner. If you’re dropping by for breakfast, don’t hesitate to order their Breakfast Burrito or Mexican Skillet. For a simpler but filling option, you can have their Egg and Brie Sandwich.
What we love most about Keys Bite is the fact that it opens as early as 7:00 AM. If you want to take a break from typical waffles, French toasts, and sausages, Keys Bite is the place to be.
Cuisine: Mexican, Latin, Seafood
Serves: 07:00 AM – 9:00 PM Sunday to Thursday, 07:00 AM – 10:00 PM Friday to Saturday
Price Range: $8-$20
Outdoor Seating: Available
Reservations Required: Not required
What The Fish Rolls & More
What The Fish Rolls is a perfect and fresh taste of the Archipelago’s best offerings: seafood. The restaurant was inspired by the island’s culture and flavorful takes on what is locally available. Their menu is composed of ocean-to-table specialties such as crab cakes, lobster rolls, seafood buns, and ready-to-eat entrées.
If you’re a local, this place is the best option to take your friends who are visiting the area because of its quality eats and laid-back vacation atmosphere.
For food at this Key Largo restaurant, try their Yellow Tail Ceviche del Mar, Crab Roll, and Casa Mar Roll – all served with surprising, delicious sides.
Cuisine: American, Seafood, Gluten-Free Options
Serves: 11:00 AM – 5:30 PM Tuesday to Thursday & Sunday, 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM Friday to Saturday
Price Range: $7.50-$15
Outdoor Seating: Available
Reservations Required: Not required
The Fish House
The Fish House is a hidden gem unexpectedly tucked in a local strip mall. Though quite underrated, The Fish House is known around locals as a daily go-to for quality seafood.
The place may not look much, but their focus is clear in their main motto: “We are not fancy, we are fresh.” Probably not the place to go if you’re staying for a day, but if you live in the area or staying for a longer time, you’ll appreciate this place – no doubt.
This is definitely one of the best Key Largo restaurants for incredibly fresh and yummy seafood.
Cuisine: Seafood, Cajun/Creole
Serves: 11:30 AM – 10:00 PM Tuesday to Sunday
Price Range: Starts at $11.50
Outdoor Seating: Not available
Reservations Required: Takes reservations but is not required
The Buzzard’s Roost
The Buzzard’s Roost is one of the unique seafood spots in the area, offering fresh takes on the seafood chain. They also offer fun signature cocktails like Smashed Buzzard (Light Rum and Coconut Rum shaken with tropical fruit juices, pina colada, and blue curacao, on the rocks), Fuzzy Buzzard (Coconut Rum, Peach Schnapps, Banana Liqueur, and Pineapple Juice), and Rum Runner (A classic Florida Keys libation. Smooth fruit flavors with plenty of rum. Blended with ice).
If you wish to get a taste of Key Largo’s exceptional seafood offerings and all while having a good time, The Buzzard’s Roost should definitely be on your list. This is one of the best restaurants in Key Largo when you’re looking to rewind with some alcoholic beverages!
Cuisine: Seafood, Pub, American
Serves:
- 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM Monday to Thursday & Sunday
- 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Friday to Saturday
Price Range: Lunch Menu starts at $9.95
Outdoor Seating: Available
Reservations Required: Takes reservations
Hobo’s Cafe
Hobo’s Cafe offers comfort seafood options with the American palate in mind. The cafe is situated in a homey dining area with a bar and an outdoor patio. This place really knows how to tingle your senses from the food to the ambiance that they provide.
The only thing you have to consider is the wideness of their menu. The various options can be a bit overwhelming and a recommendation from their staff is a bit of help. Or you can start by ordering their Clam Chowder Soup and decide from there, which is what I always do. If you’re still feeling indecisive, try their Mahi Mahi Quesadillas, Key Lime Chicken, and Conch Fritters, all of which are amazing!
This is one of the best restaurants in Key Largo if you want to try true “Keys” food and get the authentic, local experience in a gorgeous spot.
Cuisine: American, Seafood, Burgers
Serves: 11:00 AM – 9:30 PM Daily
Price Range: $12 to $30
Outdoor Seating: Available
Reservations Required: Not required
Lazy Lobster
Lazy Lobster is another seafood restaurant to check out in Key Largo. Like Hobo’s, they have an extensive menu that’s fit for everyone. It is the perfect spot to impress and invite your family and friends with very diverse tastes.
For the mains, try their fresh Lobster Roll, Fried Whole Snapper, and Medium Crab Claws. For dessert, order their bestselling Key Lime Pie with traditional toasted meringue topping.
Their spacious patio seating is perfect for larger gatherings as well. It’s a great restaurant in Key Largo to bring friends and family!
Cuisine: American, Seafood, Vegetarian
Serves 11:00 AM – 9:30 PM Monday to Thursday & Sunday, 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Friday to Saturday
Price Range: $8-$30
Outdoor Seating: Available
Reservations Required: Takes reservations
The Catch
The Catch is one of Key Largo locals’ go-to hang-out spot. The ambiance is casual and their menu offerings are the ultimate comfort food. The owners are almost always present and you can see how they engage with local regulars.
This seafood heaven has the best Homemade Rum Cake and Stuffed Crab Cake Appetizers. Their Shrimp Bruschetta is also to die for. If you’re going to Keys alone, this is probably one of the best seafood choices to consider.
You should definitely try this Key Largo restaurant at least once during your trip to get the real experience.
Cuisine: Seafood, Barbecue
Serves: 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM Monday to Thursday & Sunday
Price Range: $5-$29
Outdoor Seating: Available
Reservations Required: Walk-ins are welcome
Pizza:
If you’re looking for something a little more homey and normal then you’ll love these pizza restaurants in Key Largo. You’ll find everything from artisanal pizza to the classic house of pizza chain on this list!
Italian Food Company
Italian Food Company says it right on its name. This restaurant is one of the notable Italian restaurants serving top-tier pizzas, high-quality wines, and authentic Italian desserts.
Locals say it’s “all about the crust” which is true – this pizza is super unique and delicious. It’s one of my favorite restaurants in Key Largo when we want an Italian night!
If you’re visiting, try their Burrata Salad with Prosciutto, Bolognese Spaghetti, and Margherita pizza. Give the table something to celebrate with a bottle of Cabernet, which is always a good way to finish off the night here.
Cuisine: Italian, Pizza
Serves: 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM Sunday-Monday & Tuesday-Thursday, 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM Friday-Saturday
Price Range: Starts at $10
Outdoor Seating: Available
Reservations Required: Not required
C&C Wood Fired Eats
C&C Wood Fired Eats provides fresh wood-fired pizzas, meats, and bites that are easy to fall in love with. They also specialize in Artisanal Cheeses, Salads, and Sandwiches that go best with a carafe of their high-quality wines.
Visit them during their daily Happy Hour from 4-6 PM for a quality meal with a drink for less. If you’re stopping by for late lunch or dinner, order their Wood-Fired Wings, Marinara Meatballs, and their Margherita Pizza. Enjoy that all with lovely music playing in the background.
Cuisine: American, Pizza, Dining bars
Serves: 4:00 PM – 10:00 PM Monday to Saturday, 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM Sunday
Price Range: Pizzas start at $16
Outdoor Seating: Not available
Reservations Required: Not required
Tower Of Pizza
Tower Of Pizza is not just known for selling pizzas, but also for putting a surprisingly generous amount of toppings on their pizza. The place may be a little cramped, but their offerings are not to be underestimated.
Some of the best choices from this little pizza place are their Tower Supreme Pizza, Meat Eaters Delight Pizza, and Italian Toss Salad. This is the type of Pizzeria where you’d want to order something unconventional!
If you’re hosting a dinner party at home, this is the best place to get your pizza.
Cuisine: Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian Options
Serves:11:00 AM – 8:00 PM Monday to Thursday & Sunday, 11:00 AM – 8:30 PM Friday and Saturday
Outdoor Seating: Not available
Reservations Required: Walk-ins are welcome
Upper Crust Pizza
Another commendable and fun hole-in-the-wall Pizza place can be found within walking distance from the Key Largo Kampground. Their Luncheonette Style Decor can bring you back to wholesome memories at home.
Upper Crust Pizza is a pizza diner in Key Largo where you’d want to invite your pack over a late brunch get-together. Order their Caprese Pizza, Seafood Alfredo, and Egg Plant Parm Pizza for an out-of-the-box option.
Cuisine: Pizza, Italian
Serves: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Daily except for Wednesdays
Price Range: Pizzas start at $12 to $20
Outdoor Seating: Not available
Reservations Required: Not required
Cafe/Brunch:
If you’re on vacation then you definitely need to check out brunch restaurants in Key Largo!
Harriette’s Restaurant
Looking for a quick brunch spot for the day? Harriette’s is one of the classic local brunch spots to get a nice Breakfast Burrito, Eggs Benedict, French Toast, or Conch Burger.
And when I say brunch, I mean it! The portions are so big that you can share them among a pair of small to average-eaters.
If you’re looking for a restaurant in Key West to gas up before a long day, this is the place to be. Don’t forget to try their unique homemade muffins too!
Cuisine: American, Cafe, Diner, Breakfast, Brunch
Serves: 6:00 AM – 3:00 PM Daily
Price Range: $3-$15
Outdoor Seating: None
Reservations Required: Not required
Doc’s Diner
Another brunch restaurant in Key Largo you should consider after a long night is Doc’s Diner. They offer breakfast options with very large portions and everyday breakfast specials that are very affordable at $7.99. They also have hangover recovery food which is ideal for those who just had a heavy night of drinking.
Their bestsellers include Hashbrown Casserole, Tropical French Toast, Breakfast burrito, and Fiesta Skillet. Extra hungry? Go order that Fiesta Skillet as you please.
The atmosphere is laid-back and old-school, cozy enough to start the day ahead.
Cuisine: American, Italian, Breakfast, Brunch
Serves: 6:00 AM – 2:00 PM Daily
Price Range: Weekday Breakfast starts at $7.99
Outdoor Seating: Not available
Reservations Required: Not required
Over Easy
Over Easy is an unassuming Key Largo brunch spot in the back corner of Winn Dixie Market, a strip mall in Tavernier. Locals say that the food in this spot just doesn’t match how exceptional their breakfast offerings are. But the restaurant is not to be underestimated.
Try their Banana Nut French Toast, Chicken and Waffles, and Chilaquiles Bowl (protein-packed entree for vegetarians). The waffle is different from usual, it was thin, crispy, and very notable. The interior is pretty laid-back and modern, adding to the vibrance of their food offerings. Their brand aesthetic can evidently recognize that this restaurant is established just recently.
Cuisine: American, Cafe, Breakfast, Brunch
Serves: 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM Daily
Outdoor Seating: Not available
Reservations Required: Walk-ins welcome
Made 2 Order
Made 2 Order is a quaint, charming nook that offers fine breakfast options with a tint of Key Largo. They are one of the notable brunch spots in the keys that offer both American breakfasts and fusion-filled options.
For their American options, try their Tropical French Toast, Crab Cake Benedict, and Croissant French Toast. For an Islander twist, order their Ahi Tuna Club Sandwich, Islander Breakfast Sandwich, or Crab Cake Benedict. Their food is made of high-quality ingredients and the way they present them is so Instagrammable!
Because they are a small shop with minimal staff, their service can be a bit delayed. Bring a friend over brunch and enjoy a good conversation while waiting for the food. Regardless, the quality of this Key Largo restaurant’s offerings is definitely worth the wait!
Cuisine: American (New), Breakfast & Brunch
Serves: 8:00 AM – 3:00 PM
Outdoor Seating: Not available
Reservations Required: Not required
Italian:
Even though the keys aren’t known for Italian food, there are a bunch of great Italian restaurants in Key Largo that we always enjoy.
Old Tavernier
Old Tavernier is an old, 30-year old, pioneering Italian restaurant in the Keys. If you ask a local in Tavernier, they are sure to recognize this place.
Old Tavernier serves authentic Italian food from pizzas, beef, to seafood. Unlike other Italian restaurants, Old Tavernier is mostly known for their entrees than their pizza. Their pizza is exceptional, but their food is a definite must-try. If you’re visiting Old Tavernier, order their Caesar Salad with Black Anchovy, Moscow Oysters, and Key Lime Pie. To add a celebratory mood to the table, get a glass of Dirty Martini to pair with your food.
Cuisine: Italian, American
Serves 4:00 PM – 10:00 PM Monday to Thursday & Sunday, 4:00 PM – 11:00 PM
Friday to Saturday
Price Range: $4 to $35
Outdoor Seating: Patio
Reservations Required:
DiGiorgio ‘s Cafe Largo
It’s hard to find Italian restaurants that don’t just serve pizza. Unlike its competitors, DiGiorgio’s Cafe in Key Largo highlights its pasta, local seafood, veal, and delicious Tiramisu in its menu.
If you’re planning to visit, go ahead and try their Lobster Mac and Cheese, Shrimp Piccata, and Marinara pasta. For a light snack, get a cup of espresso and classic cannolis. There are so much more to choose from, so go check them out!
This place is well-loved as the pioneering Italian restaurant in the Key Largo area. If you’re looking for a variety of Italian restaurants to choose from, DiGiorgio’s is a great option to consider.
Cuisine: Italian
Price Range: $8 to $38
Outdoor Seating: Not available
Reservations Required: Takes reservations but walk-ins are welcome
Asian:
There are also some great Asian restaurants in Key Largo, from comfort Chinese food to upscale Asian cuisine.
Great Wall
Chinese cravings? Key Largo has it! Great Wall is one of the best and pioneering Chinese food in Tavernier. They serve everything in large portions and the ingredients are clearly high-quality despite being in the budget tier.
Try their Lo Mein Noodles, Vegetable Platter, Sesame Chicken, and Kung Pao Chicken for a flavorful and filling meal. For a classic treat, order their Potstickers or Crab Rangoon. The place is neat, clean, and straightforward. Their staff is also friendly and always ready to help if you need changes in your food.
Cuisine: Chinese, Asian, Cantonese
Serves: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Monday & Wednesday to Saturday, 11:00 AM – 9:30 PM Sunday
Outdoor Seating: Not available
Reservations Required: Not required
Cheng Garden
Cheng Garden is another notable Asian restaurant in the Keys that features both Chinese and Thai dishes. What we love about this Asian restaurant most are its friendly and very approachable owners. I
f you need to eat something specific because of your dietary needs, do not hesitate to ask the owners the best options they have. They serve quick and classic meals that can surely fill your tummy in no time.
Go ahead and try their Fried Wontons, Teriyaki Chicken, Egg Drop Soup, and Sweet and Sour Chicken. Pair it with a cup of white rice and you’re good to go!
Cuisine: Chinese
Serves: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM Monday to Thursday, 11:00 AM – 10:30 PM Friday to Saturday, 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM Sunday
Price Range: $1.50-$11
Outdoor Seating: Not available
Reservations Required: Takes reservations
Num Thai Restaurant and Sushi Bar
Num Thai Restaurant and Sushi Bar is one of the many Thai Seafood restaurants in Key Largo. They offer exceptional Sushi, classic Stir Fry Vegetables, and our favorite Pad Thai.
Locals agree that this Thai restaurant offers the best Pad Thai in the area. For the quality and the beautiful “Bali-like” ambiance, the prices are very affordable. The most memorable part of their dining experience is their in-house robot that serves and delivers your orders to the table. It was definitely something else!
Cuisine: Thai
Serves: 11:30 AM – 3:00 PM & 5:00 PM – 10:00 PM Monday to Friday, 5:00 PM – 10:00 PM Saturday-Sunday
Price Range: $2.50-$11.50
Outdoor Seating: Not available
Reservations Required:
The Key Thai Restaurant and Sushi Bar
The Key Thai Restaurant and Sushi Bar are among the pioneering Thai restaurants in the Keys that are hard to miss. Quite literally, actually! Despite being tucked in a strip mall, their sign is so large that it’s hard to miss when you walk by.
Their notable food is their sweet Mango with Sticky Rice. The flavors on each entree were also authentic and the portions were large enough to take a bit more leftovers home. Their Tuna Tataki, Drunken Noodles, and Cashew Chicken are also to die for. If you’re in the area, make sure you drop by this charming Thai place!
Cuisine: Thai
Serves: 12:00 PM – 3:00 PM & 5:00 PM – 9:30 PM Daily except for Tuesdays
Price Range: $5-$11
Outdoor Seating: Not available
Reservations Required: Walk-ins are welcome
Maki Sushi Thai
Maki Sushi Thai has the most delicious Ahi Bomb and Teriyaki plates. This little sushi restaurant used to be located on the premises of The Bayside Inn. This quaint sushi place offers sushi with the freshest ingredients assembled with care.
For their food, go ahead and try their Ahi Bomb with mango crab sushi rolls, Pad Thai for a classic continental treat, and Nigiri rolls for the sushi cravings.
They’re temporarily closed, but they are planning to re-open in a nearby location. You can check their official page for more updates.
Cuisine: Japanese, Sushi, Asian, Thai
Serves: 11:30 AM – 3:00 PM & 5:00 PM – 10:00 PM Monday to Friday, 5:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Saturday-Sunday
Outdoor Seating: Available
Reservations Required: Takes reservations
J-Dao Sushi Thai
Can you tell that sushi restaurants in Key Largo are pretty popular?
J-Dao Sushi Thai is a sushi place for special occasions and intimate celebrations. Unlike other casual sushi places, J-Dao offers a nice classy atmosphere and exceptional food presentation.
This place is a great option to consider if you are inviting someone over dinner, whether they are locals or visitors. Vegans and vegetarians are welcome here too! Simply ask their staff for their ‘vegan/vegetarian options on the menu and they would be happy to help.
Definitely try their Sushi Boat, Red Curry, Tom Yum Goong Soup, and Vegetarian Egg Rolls. For dessert, order their Fried Ice Cream.
Cuisine: Thai
Serves:
11:00 AM – 3:00 PM & 5:00 PM – 10:00 PM Monday to Friday, 5:00 PM – 10:00 PM Saturday-Sunday
Price Range: Starts at $7.95
Outdoor Seating: Not available
Reservations Required: Takes reservations
Las Olas Ceviche Bar
Last on our list for the Sushi category is Las Olas Ceviche Bar. This charming sushi bar is tucked away in the lobby of the famous Playa Largo resort. They offer Ceviche, Tuna Rolls, and unique Asian desserts like their amazing Ice Cream Sandwich. They also pour cocktails in case you need a little something to add spark to the table.
The ambiance is relaxing, laid-back, and lounge-like. Because they close late (12:00 AM Next Day), Las Olas makes a good night out spot.
Cuisine: Sushi, Peruvian
Serves: 5:00 PM – 12:00 AM Daily
Outdoor Seating: Not available
Reservations Required: Not required
Healthy/Vegetarian:
If you’re an ambitious traveler who wants to stay healthy on vacation, you’ll find plenty of restaurants in Key Largo to suit your needs.
Grati Cafe
Grati “Gratitude” Cafe is an islanders haven. They offer Island Fusions, Fresh Juices, and healthy meals by the dock. By far, they have the best Acai Bowls in Key Largo. Plus, their location hit the right spot.
Apart from their healthy and phenomenal bowls, they also have other savory options like Veggie Wrap, Chicken Avocado Bomb, and Sriracha Chicken Sandwiches. On a hot day, I recommend getting their naturally sweet Dragonfruit smoothie.
A lot of creative and friendly locals also come by this place which will make you love Gratis even more!
Cuisine: Island Fusion
Serves: 10:00 AM – 5:00 PM Daily
Price Range: $3-$13
Outdoor Seating: Not available but takeouts are offered/recommended
Reservations Required: Walk-ins only
Coco Plum Place
Coco Plum Place is the place-to-be for vegans and breakfast food lovers. Despite the slightly pricey rates, you get more than you pay with their high-quality and creative meals. Since they open at 8:30 AM, you can easily drop by for breakfast before starting a day tour around town or before a long day at the beach.
Try their Coco Plum Acai Bowl, Avocado Toast, Vegan Breakfast Burrito, and Chocolate Chip Muffins! For lemon lovers, their lemon bars are a must-try. Compared to similar vegan/vegetarian restaurants in Key Largo, Coco Plum has a wider variety that can even make a non-vegan squirm with delight!
Cuisine: American, Cafe, Deli, Contemporary, Healthy
Serves: 8:30 AM – 4:30 PM Daily
Outdoor Seating: Available
Reservations Required: Walk-ins only
Leave a Reply